Blog Widget by LinkWithin
Sponsor

Follow Me

Get the RSS@blacksnob on TwitterFacebookEmail the Snob

 Search The Snob:

Keep The Snob Alive!
Get Your Swag On!

snob swag 220 animated

Sponsor

General Snobbery
Sponsor

« Danyel Smith No Longer With The Root | Main | Michelle Obama: Hula Hoop/Double-Dutch Star »
Friday
Oct232009

Give It Up For the HNIC! ... Wait? What?

St. Petersburg Mayoral candidate Kathleen Ford quoted Cornel West's HNIC comment and got herself some criticism for it.Part of some of the criticism about Warren Ballentine telling Juan Williams he could "go back to the porch" came from those who felt Ballentine shouldn't have used a term blacks throw around among themselves in public. "What would happen if others started using it!?!?" some wondered. Everyone knows there are a lot of terms just used by black people, for black people and against black people that would ... er ... not sound as kosher coming out of the mouths of a non-black person.

Case in point the term "HNIC," aka "Head Negro (nee, nigger) In Charge."

More after the jump.

This term is old and dusty. It's not remotely new, used by young and old black people alike as both a benign, but colorful commentary on the black electorate/leadership and random black people in charge of things (i.e. Oprah Winfery would be the HNIC of all media), to a racially charged insult. In some cases, it's been used as an indictment against older, more recalcitrant blacks with political power who sometimes seem more trouble than their worth. Essentially, it's a term that's not supposed to leave the community because when used by anyone else it would be seen as an unfunny insult. It's not even polite to use the term in mixed company after all, or even around some black people in other cases. (i.e. My mother, who hates all derivatives of the N-word no matter how dressed up.)

So enter one St. Petersburg, Fla. mayoral candidate Kathleen Ford who, during a radio interview, used the term HNIC in reference to her opponent. Ford is white. Her opponent, Deputy Mayor Goliath Davis, is black. Ford explained she was using the term in the context of a Cornel West quote about black leadership from his book, "Race Matters."

Here is what West said about the HNIC in his book:

The time is past for black political and intellectual leaders to pose as the voice for black America....The days of brokering for the black turf--of posing as the Head Negro in Charge (H.N.I.C.) are over. (From AOL/Blackvoices)

And here is what Ford said on the radio show:

"Actually Cornell West has a whole explanation about the HNIC theory, and I agree with that," Ford told Bubba during an hourlong radio interview. "We don't need one spokesperson for a group." (From Tampa Bay Online)

Aw! Someone learned a new word and is about to get slaughtered for it!

Despite having Cornel West as the context, Ford is taking heat for using the term HNIC. Apparently no one informed her that HNIC is not a formal or polite term, not even in Blackland. You can't just bust out with HNIC Theory, apropos of nothing. It's just not done. Enter your black ministers and other random people to scream "WELL, I NEVER!"

From Tampa Bay Online:

Ford's remark doesn't sit well with Baptist minister and longtime civic leader Watson Haynes II, one of an impromptu coalition of about 30 religious and civic leaders who gathered at City Hall on Monday to protest her comment.

"We've been through a lot of riots in the city and I've been in the middle of them trying to quell stuff, trying to bring people to the table," Haynes said. "And it's these kinds of inflammatory statements that get people excited."

Deveron Gibbons, who made an unsuccessful bid to become St. Petersburg's first black mayor before losing in the primary election, also was critical of Ford.

"Whether she intended to make a racial comment, it was racial and it's not appreciated, not just by African-Americans but you can see who's here — a total community of folks from all walks of life," Gibbons said.

David Zachem, who is white and a self-described former civil rights marcher in the 1960s, joined Gibbons and Haynes in objecting to Ford's radio remark. "That phrase rolls the clock back 50 years in Florida and in many communities in the South," Zachem said.

Zachem said the "head negro in charge" expression refers to an old patronage system which favored black leaders who rounded up votes for white politicians and were rewarded with business licenses and permits when the candidates they helped were elected.

Not everyone was offended though, given the Cornel West context of how Ford used the term. NAACP rep Ray Tampa said everyone was blowing the incident out of proportion.

Ray Tampa, the head of the St. Petersburg NAACP, said he thinks many of those who showed up to criticize Ford were there for political reasons. He said he was not offended because Ford was using the term in an academic discussion about race.

"It's an offensive term, it's offensive, but in the context Ms. Ford used it, it was not offensive,'' Tampa said.

The term is offensive, but Ford used the Cornel West context to use the word. So really, this was about a quote, not so much as a direct slander. Still, the term HNIC shouldn't be used publically by anyone trying to be polite and professional. So some frowny faces for Ford as she probably should have thought that one through a little more before she proudly busted out her amazing Cornel West quote book. After all, Prof. West says A LOT of things that would sit will with "polite society" and shouldn't be ushered by people trying to get a decent job in this economy. Especially if you're depending on some black people to actually show up and vote for you. But perhaps she wanted to display how down for the cause she is. "I read Cornel West! I'm with it!" she thought, "Listen to how 'with it' I sound!" Sort of like your white friend who screams out the word "nigga" along to the Jay-Z track. It's within a Jay-Z context! Why are you giving him the death stare?

Let this be a "teachable moment," so to speak. We've not gotten so far that other members of different ethnic groups can use other ethnic groups' "inside voice" terms without getting reprimanded. We're just not that enlightened yet. Throw around your Cornel West quotes accordingly.

Also, for those who this note isn't obvious enough for, here's a list of random racial terms that are not appropriate for polite society:

All derivatives of the N-word
Sambo
Porch Monkey
Lawn Jockey
Buck
All derivatives of monkey, ape or gorilla
Jungle Bunny
Jiggaboo
Peckerwood
Redneck
White Trash
Hillbilly
Okie
Coon
Bobo/Miss Anne/Mister Charlie
Darkie
HNIC
Negro
Colored
Hankerchief Head
Uncle Tom
Etc., etc., herefore and henceforth ... I'm sure I'm forgetting one or 12.

EmailEmail Article to Friend

Reader Comments (20)

I can’t even beginning to understand what she was thinking. I think she was trying to show how ‘down’ or ‘wit it’, she was but quoting West. She probably didn’t mean it in a mean spirited way, but I can’t understand why she thought it was appropriate at all. In the end, this is going to turn into one of those ‘how come they can say it, but we can’t’ situations.

October 23, 2009 | Unregistered Commenterconni3

What!?! No more you-might-be-a-r*dn*ck jokes?

Not even in the context of a James Foxworthy quote?

Or am I safe because it would be an intra-racial joke in my case?

Bad because I am a damn yankee?

Gonna have to keep it on the down low.

October 23, 2009 | Registered CommenterAabaakawad

We shouldn't be surprised this happened considering the number of non Black people wondering (complaining) why they can't use the "n" word when Black people can.

October 23, 2009 | Unregistered CommenterLarry

Nothing to see here, controvery wise. She's totally within the bounds of the terms use.

But Juan Williams still needs a swift kick in the sack, if you know what I mean....

October 23, 2009 | Unregistered Commentersnobfanforeal'

I believe they call it "hate speech", but you forgot Kike, Ofay, swartzer, ect. Professors Cornell West and Henry Louis Gates are negores white people went out and found and said - "Here, Black people, this is your genuises". Who said "Harvard has destroyed more negroes than cheap whiskey?" If the jewsih media owners ever say a Black person is "our" speaker, I do not follow them. They were the same one's who went out and found Malcolm X in New York to oppose Dr. King with the sole purpose of bringing down the Honorable Elijah Muhammed and the Nation of Islam. Know your enemies, people.

October 23, 2009 | Unregistered CommenterAce

The "frowny faces" are deserved more for @1) someone naming their child Bubba and (2) Ford espousing her thoughts on the efficacy of Black community leadership...period. There's no link (not even in the Tampa Bay article) to the original audio interview.

Based on the short snippet above, though, she could have put ANY word in that sentence but her point is clear and from the standpoint of privilege it would have flopped no matter which words she used.

But really...Bubba?

October 23, 2009 | Unregistered Commentermalted_tea

"Mister Charlie" was a term I'm not familiar with - Urban Dictionary entry on it is pretty interesting:
http://www.urbandictionary.com/define.php?term=Mr.+Charlie&defid=1288599

And while I'm commenting, congratulations on the new job Danielle!

October 23, 2009 | Unregistered CommenterAnn

Take me to your HNIC.

October 23, 2009 | Unregistered CommenterDavid Wise

.

October 23, 2009 | Unregistered CommenterJohn D.

@ D Wise...lol

October 24, 2009 | Unregistered Commenterdkan71

It does not surprise me a white person would say this in public. Since Obama has been in office, some white people think it is cool to relate to black people. I once had a white co-worker tell me he was "On colored peoples time today". After he said that, I took leave for 3 days to calm day.

October 24, 2009 | Unregistered CommenterKevin

"I'm sure I'm forgetting one or 12"

like any that are pertinent to asians.

October 24, 2009 | Unregistered Commenterswiv

Your list of pejorative words more or less equates peckerwood, redneck, white trash, hillbilly, and okie (you could easily have included cracker, too). But those terms are not nearly so offensive -- in fact, at times not at all offensive -- as any derivative of the n-word. Sometimes they are proudly used: for example, here in Atlanta, the Redneck Underground refers to a group of country, country rock, and rockabilly musicians who absolutely despise the pop crap Nashville produces and want to get back to the real country sounds of the 1940s, 1950s, and 1960s. Merle Haggard's "Okie From Muscogee" is another example. The terms can be used pejoratively, but it depends on the tone of voice and the context in which they're uttered.
In any event, these terms referring to white people do not carry nearly the historical weight of the n-word. So, I don't think it's a good idea to equate them.
@ Ann: check out James Baldwin's "Blues for Mister Charlie."

October 24, 2009 | Unregistered Commenterhoodoowah

@Kevin:

Wow--that's so ridiculous! I hope you told him that was NOT okay.

October 24, 2009 | Unregistered CommenterApril

Still trying find creative ways to sneak in the so-called n-word...corny!

October 26, 2009 | Unregistered Commentercdf

i love comparing racial slurs and seeing which one is worse. it's my favorite past time.

October 26, 2009 | Unregistered Commenterswiv

you forgot all the anti-mexican/latino/hispanic references.

I am officially offended.

;)

October 26, 2009 | Unregistered CommenterSteph

When Cornell West wrote his book, did he mention that HNIC was offensive?

I mean if a person never heard the term before and a read it a book by Ivy League professor, most people would start dropping into sentences. "Hey look mom, I'm well-read"

Cornell West (yes, boo-boo Cornell West because white folk know who are you which apparently that's bad in a country that's over a three-quarters White) is more too blame for an assumption of what is and isn't offensive. Even I loose track sometimes.

Also, are people offended by whites using the term or the concept?
Are whites allowed to be critical of black politicians?
Even if there is the minority, Bill Jefferson, Bobby Rush and Charlie Rangel went represent some whites, right?

October 29, 2009 | Unregistered CommenterE.A.I.

Much too late on this comment, but here goes.....Damn, we certainly have a different view of the world and race relations here North of the Border... not that there aren't various forms of racism in Canada...but the great majority of Canucks would see the letters HNIC, and INSTANTLY translate them into........wait for it.....Hockey Night In Canada.....which Saturday nights have been referred to for over 80 years.

November 18, 2009 | Unregistered CommenterDrBOP

You forgot Aunt Jemima. lol

January 13, 2010 | Unregistered CommenterErica Jane

PostPost a New Comment

Enter your information below to add a new comment.

My response is on my own website »
Author Email (optional):
Author URL (optional):
Post:
 
Some HTML allowed: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <code> <em> <i> <strike> <strong>

better people